Question Thank you for your response. Please clarify further the following questions. Q1: Please define a nation? Is nation a country or collection of a religious countries? Are Israelites and Ishmaelites considered nations ONLY? Does Israelites and Ishmaelites nations exist in the present times. You write in your original response, As for the first part […]
A Narrative Ascribed to the Prophet (pbuh) Relating to Da`wah
Question In your response to the question regarding on joining group for the propagation, you have written that: In fact, the very idea of propagating Islam outside one’s own area is not based on either the Qur’an or the Sunnah. Then I would like to know what Prophet (pbuh) means by saying in his last […]
Further Clarification on Sects in Islam
Question Thanks for the response regarding my first question. I would like to know your opinion on these particular aspects of the tablighi Jama`ah. Here in Malaysia, they have the 1/10 rule meaning that you have to go out (doing the tablighi [i.e. propagation] work outside your area) for 3 days in a month, 40 […]
Mr. Jochen Katz’ and Mr. Jacque Weddle’s Comments…
Question The First Comment The problem is that you might convince some or even a good number of already peacefully inclined Muslims, but will this “automatically” lead to change? No, if everyone waits for somebody else to take up political action then very little will be done and the field is still left to those […]