Question Thank you for your reply. You write: However, it is not a scientific fact that man’s behavior is mechanical enough to be brought under the scope of the scientific principle of cause and effect. But does my judgment still not require some cause, however “mechanical” or “non-mechanical”? If we say man has complete moral […]

Question In principle you seem justified as regards your answer. But one question arises that anyhow the dream came true and the sultan in fact picked up the conspiracy and finally saved the Prophet (pbuh) as desired by him (pbuh) in the vision? Answer It is one thing to acknowledge that a particular vision or […]

Question I have read your replies to the issue of free-will and predestination. I have the following questions/comments: The idea of free-will contradicts the scientific principle of cause and effect. If I do an action, I do so because of some cause. If actions had no cause, then they would be arbitrary, impulsive and make […]

Question In your answer to a question tilted “Regarding the Prophets for Jinn“, you have written: Just as no Jinn could be sent as a prophet towards the human race, no human being could be sent as a prophet towards the race of the Jinn. One of the basic reasons for this general rule is […]

Question Thank you for your response. I think you didn’t get the last part of my question. My question was, why did Prophet (pbuh) gave the punishment of Jizya on Magians when they were polytheists because according to God’s law relating to messengers, only the monotheistic people are subjected to Jizya punishment. Secondly, do you […]

Question I just wanted to add a little information to this discussion.  Not only is Prophet Adam’s birth a greater miracle than the birth of Jesus but almost every miracle Jesus performed was paralleled by another prophet. i.e. feeding of a great amount of people with little food was also performed by Elijah (I Kings […]