Gaza and Israel: the response of Senator Abdul El-Sayed

Gaza and Israel: the response of Senator Abdul El-Sayed

It was in Washington, Tuesday, November 17, 2026, that Abdul El-Sayed, newly elected Democratic senator in Michigan, was questioned about his criticism of Israel and the fear of anti-Semitism. He was speaking at “The Atlantic Summit: Politics, Power, and What’s Next”, a forum of the American magazine The Atlantic organized the day after the mid-term elections.

In this excerpt broadcast by C-SPAN, his interlocutor asks him to stand in front of a person who would come and confide his concern to him. What would he say to her if she explained to him that his speeches on Israel feed his fear of anti-Semitism? El-Sayed responds to her as if she were in front of him. “I’m sorry you’re scared” (“I’m sorry for your fear”), he declares, before specifying that he does not wish, through his words or his actions, to expose anyone to danger.

The elected senator then introduces a distinction between fear for his safety and the discomfort that denouncing an injustice can cause. “Injustice inflicted on others should make you uncomfortable” (“You should be uncomfortable with injustice perpetrated on other people”), he says. Then he returns the question. What exactly are we asking him to keep quiet about? In Gaza, he speaks of 70,000 people killed, houses destroyed, hospitals destroyed and universities devastated.

It is on the place given to these Palestinian lives that he concludes. If the fear or discomfort of his interlocutor were to impose silence on him in the face of such destruction, he explains, he would then have to accept the moral consequence. “What you’re telling me is that their humanity matters less than yours. » His final words in English are equally direct: “Their humanity matters less than yours.”